Preservation volunteers told The Times Herald of phantom cat sounds in Selma's basement, whispered words near visitors' ears and an electrically disconnected bedroom buzzer heard ringing. Investigators also described a dark form rising from a bathtub in the former servants' bathroom, an account tied specifically to the third floor.
Ghost-tour accounts place a rifle-carrying Union soldier on the inn's staircase, marching before disappearing into a room. Guests also describe footsteps above the Blue Room and a figure sitting on a bed. Children's apparitions and a spectral cat give the inn's folklore a more domestic side.
Bucks County's bridge-history project records Van Sant's as a crybaby bridge. In the legend, a woman kills her child and herself, leaving cries that are said to linger after dark. The tragic backstory is folklore; the source does not establish an actual death corresponding to the tale.