Casey's Cottage at Mexico Point State Park

The Story

After William Casey died in 1978, visitors to the carriage house he transformed into a medieval-style cottage began reporting faint organ music, cries for help and moving furniture. Other accounts describe candles falling from shelves, keys reappearing in odd places and a young girl near a tree. The alleged burial associated with that apparition remains part of the story.

The Hauntings

After William Casey died in 1978, visitors to the carriage house he transformed into a medieval-style cottage began reporting faint organ music, cries for help and moving furniture. Other accounts describe candles falling from shelves, keys reappearing in odd places and a young girl near a tree. The alleged burial associated with that apparition remains part of the story.

A sense of place.

Visitor Experiences

Have you experienced something here?

This future chapter will bring together stories from the PHASM community. An unexpected encounter, a lingering feeling, or a quiet visit—your experience will be welcome.

Submissions are not open yet.

Sources & further reading.

• Casey's Cottage at Mexico Point State Park | Haunted History Trail of New York State (reports)
• Casey's Cottage at Mexico Point State Park | Haunted History Trail of New York State (visiting)

Plan Your Visit

Cottage tours and investigations require advance arrangements; park access does not automatically grant building entry.