John F. Craig House
Cape May, New Jersey, United States
Hotel · local-legend
The Story
The directory's former-guest folklore assigns different residents to rooms 4 and 5. In the Susan Craig Room, people reportedly encountered an unidentified red-haired girl. The Lucy Johnson Room was linked to Lucy herself, remembered as a helpful spirit who supposedly replaced missing buttons on guests' clothing.
The Hauntings
The directory's former-guest folklore assigns different residents to rooms 4 and 5. In the Susan Craig Room, people reportedly encountered an unidentified red-haired girl. The Lucy Johnson Room was linked to Lucy herself, remembered as a helpful spirit who supposedly replaced missing buttons on guests' clothing.
A sense of place.
Visitor Experiences
Have you experienced something here?
This future chapter will bring together stories from the PHASM community. An unexpected encounter, a lingering feeling, or a quiet visit—your experience will be welcome.
Submissions are not open yet.
Sources & further reading.
- John F. Craig House | Haunted Places (reports)
- John F. Craig House | Haunted Places (visiting)
Plan Your Visit
Current access and opening hours were not independently verified. Obtain site permission for any investigation; no after-hours or restricted-area entry. Research access status: closed.